Start with your priority, not the boat type
Before comparing offers, decide what matters most: sharing the trip, following an organised programme, travelling only with your group, or allowing for children and people who will not swim. A shared tour and private charter address different needs, but the label alone does not tell you which experience fits. Ask what activities are actually planned and how much room there is to discuss preferences.
Shared excursion: an organised plan for everyone
With other passengers aboard, the programme is designed for the group and may include set timings, stops and services. Before paying, check the stated duration and terms, embarkation point, any meals or equipment included, and suitability for your companions. Do not assume every stop is long or that the boat can land on any beach. Ask for a concrete route whose stops comply with current rules.
Private boat: more discussion, not unlimited access
A boat reserved for your group can make it easier to discuss priorities and pace with the skipper, within the permitted route and conditions. It does not mean you can navigate or stop anywhere, nor does it open a protected area. Ask who is in command, what boat is provided, which costs are included, and which permits or qualifications apply if the offer is bareboat rather than crewed.
Compare route, permissions and the full cost
Ask for the planned route and stopping points: a general reference to the islands is not enough to check Park or Marine Protected Area rules. Verify that the provider is authorised, which permits are required, and who handles them. Compare the total price, not just the headline figure; fuel, crew, equipment or other costs depend on the offer. Do not infer a route from a promotional photograph.
Let weather and a backup plan guide the choice
Wind and sea conditions can change plans on any boat. Before confirming, read the postponement or refund terms and ask who decides when a stop must be cancelled. Tell the provider about mobility, health or swimming needs before departure. A good choice leaves the skipper room to change course and gives your group an alternative, rather than forcing an unsafe or unauthorised stop.
Frequently asked questions
Can a private boat stop wherever it wants?
No. Route, navigation, mooring, anchoring and landing are regulated and depend on the zone and permissions. Ask for the exact itinerary and check the relevant permits with an authorised provider and the responsible authority. A private booking does not exempt anyone from Marine Protected Area or National Park rules.
What should I ask before booking?
Confirm the departure point, route and planned stops, included activities, permits, included costs, and the terms if weather or another change affects the trip. Clarify who is in command and whether the boat is shared or reserved for your group. These details make offers comparable without relying on photographs, stated duration or broad promises.